For my final paper on the argumentative essay I have been tossing around a few ideas. My blog entries have been, for the most part, about the martial arts themselves. In this paper I was thinking of taking on something with a legal aspect in regard to self defense. I think I am going to argue against Wisconsin's stand your ground law.
The Wisconsin stand your ground law states that if you feel that your life is in danger you can use deadly force without having to make an attempt to retreat. For example, if someone approaches you and says, "I'm going to kill you." you don't have the obligation to try and get away from the attacker. You could simply pull out a gun and kill the other person. I realize that this is a very simplistic example but that's the gist of it.
This idea of kill first goes against many of the principals of the traditional Martial Arts as well as some of my own fundamental beliefs. I do feel that retreat should always be the first option and should always be considered. Taking retreat out of the equation leaves a very important and deadly decision up to everyday people not equipped to make such a important choice.
Part of my decision to take on this topic was the huge amount of debate surrounding this topic and the wide availability of case studies regarding it - most recently the George Zimmerman case that divided a large number of people across the country. At the heart of that case was the stand your ground law.
There is no doubt that the Martial Arts is about self defense but at its base is the preservation of self and others. The very idea of killing before exhausting all other opportunities is something counter productive to the core belief of Martial Arts as self defense. I believe I can make a strong argument against the stand your ground law not only from a Martial Arts stand point but also from a moral and ethical standpoint as well.
i like this idea id love to hear more about the law
ReplyDeleteThis sounds like it should be a very good paper, nice idea
ReplyDeleteThis sounds interesting. Can't wait to read it.
ReplyDeleteI can't wait to hear more about this law, I did not even know it existed. I feel like even if it was my life or someone elses I know I would defend myself, but it would still be hard at a morale standpoint.
ReplyDeleteThis sounds like a very interesting and controversal topic. I believe you will have no trouble with this at all and I can't wait to read.
ReplyDeleteI don't know a lot about self defense. In my job we people are first trained they are given some training on how to block agressions. I think it will be interesting to hear about the law, who thinks it should be passed and who thinks it shouldn't be.
ReplyDelete