Wednesday, October 30, 2013

Compare and contrast

                                             

                                            Martial Arts for Self Defense or Sport



                There are similarities between the kind of martial arts used in sport martial arts and the kind that is used in self defense.  The martial arts that are used in sports (point sparring, form, and breaking competitions) incorporate a lot of the same techniques that are used for self defense.  Many of the strikes and stances are used in both styles.  Much of the physical training that goes into learning how to do a technique is also comparable.  However that is where the similarities end.
                 In any kind of sport martial art you are striving for a certain goal, whether it be winning a competition or placing in a division.  The practitioner is able to train for a situation with a controlled outcome and environment.  The practitioner knows what day the competition is, what he or she is likely to encounter and can train accordingly for the situation.  Of course in the actual competition there will be situations that the practitioner must adapt to, however most will be determined well in advance.
                 When training for self defense the martial arts take on a whole new meaning.  There are no weight classes, gender divisions, or time outs.  Every technique learned must have value in a critical situation.  If one misses a block or one's strike is weak the consequence could mean bodily harm or death, as opposed to a second place ribbon.
                Both types of martial arts have their place, however, they are night and day different.  If ever fortunate enough to see a martial arts demonstration - and the hard work and skill that goes into it - appreciate the hours spent learning those skills but do not confuse it with self defense.

9 comments:

  1. That is an interesting comparison one that I haven't thought of in a long time, Some would know what you are referring to and others might need more information of the sport. Good piece..

    ReplyDelete
  2. I know nothing about martial arts but from your articles which I enjoy reading. I did not know that training for self defense is different then training for a martial arts tournament. I thought it was all the same. I mean how can you train for self defense without using Matrial arts and where do you draw the line.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Your compare and contrast is really good. I guess I don't know much about martial arts, so it's different to read about!

    ReplyDelete
  4. I liked that you compared class martial arts to real life martial arts. Defending yourself in real life can be completely different yet you have to know the basics from class. Great compare and contrast!

    ReplyDelete
  5. I like that you point out where each kind of style is used where. I do not know much about martial arts so it was fun to read, good job

    ReplyDelete
  6. They do sound like night and day by what you said. Nice job comparing them, it was a fun read.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I liked the sentence; "If one misses a block or one's strike is weak the consequence could mean bodily harm or death, as opposed to a second place ribbon." That made the difference for me in your comparison. Good job.

    ReplyDelete
  8. this was a nice essay. i love to compete, sadly i'm not that good. i enjoyed reading thank you

    ReplyDelete
  9. I like that you choose sports martial arts compared to self defense. It was fun to read. Good job!

    ReplyDelete